Wire Structure Heat Exchangers: A Better Design for Air Cooled Condensers?

Wire Structure Heat Exchangers: A Better Design for Air Cooled Condensers?

Air cooled condensers for dry heat rejection are generally enlarged on the air side by different kind of fins, such as louvered fins, wavy fins or offset strip fins. These fins are manufactured by metal sheets and connected to the tube walls by a metal-joining process. However the possible surface area enlargement is in the range of the surface area of the underlying metal sheets.  In order to increase the surface area further on, without using more material, wire structures can be used as fins instead of metal sheets. The diameters of the wire structures are in the range of 50 to 250 µm. In addition fluid flow along wire structures experiences a very high heat transfer coefficient due to the repeating interruptions and small dimensions.

New textile developments enable the fabrication of adapted structures with non-regular grid sizes purpose-built for the specific application. The experimental proof of concept of very high heat transfer coefficients has been provided for a small scale sample heat exchanger (10 x 1 x 1 cm³). Fraunhofer ISE and Kelvion Thermal Solutions, designed thereafter a first concept of an innovative heat transfer surface area enhancement on the air side for an air-cooled condenser. The concept is based on geometrical and thermodynamic boundary conditions of an air-cooled condenser of a CSP plant in Morocco which is based on dry-cooling technology. The concept encompasses the heat transfer enhancement with a corrugated textile fabric and an adapted flat tube selection. The wire structure is oriented towards the flat tubes in order to allow good conductivity with low material consumption (see Figure 1). Performance estimation is based on CFD-Simulation of air flow through the wire structure. Therefore finite element method is used based on the software Comsol Multiphysics. Comparison of simulated performance with the reference air-cooled condenser shows a strong decrease in material consumption for the surface enhancement in the order of 40%-50%. However total mass of the heat exchanger (aluminum fins/wires and steel tubes) could be reduced by only 10% in the simulation. In the design ideas pressure drop and heat transfer rate would be in the range of the reference condenser with a slightly increased thermal effectiveness of 5% for the wire structure at equal pressure drop.

Figure 1: Wire structure embedded between flat tubes
Figure 1: Wire structure embedded between flat tubes (figure: Hannes Fugmann, Fraunhofer ISE; [1])
Simulation is based on a 2D cross section in the condenser. The simulation layer is shown in Figure 1 as part of the wire structure heat exchanger. A more detailed insight is shown in Figure 2. From the 2D-Simulation some limitations follow which are not adequately represented, such as wire contact to tubes, inhomogeneous velocities and geometrical manufacturing uncertainties. A more precise performance evaluation needs information of experimental studies to determine unknown input parameters for the simulation.

Figure 2: Cross section through a wire structure heat exchanger.
Figure 2: Cross section through a wire structure heat exchanger. Higher Velocities in red, lower velocities in blue (figure: Hannes Fugmann, Fraunhofer ISE; [2])
Within MinWaterCSP samples of wire structure heat exchangers based on the developed design ideas have been manufactured by company ENEXIO. Figure 3 shows the design of the sample heat exchanger. Different metal textiles and expanded metals have been tested for manufacturability; concentrating on material, mechanical stability, and wire arrangement. Heat exchangers with an air flow cross section of 200 mm x 200 mm have been manufactured for laboratory testing. The performance evaluation will take place at the Fraunhofer ISE ServiceLab Heat Exchangers.

Figure 3: Design of a wire structure heat exchanger for a measuring campaign at Fraunhofer ISE
Figure 3: Design of a wire structure heat exchanger for a measuring campaign at Fraunhofer ISE (figure: Hannes Fugmann, Fraunhofer ISE)

At this stage wire structure heat exchanger simulation show benefits in terms of material consumption and heat transfer characteristics, however some manufacturing, handling, and stability questions are still open and have to be considered within MinWaterCSP within the following months.



  1. Fugmann, H.; Schnabel, L.; Frohnapfel, B. Heat Transfer and Pressure Drop Correlations for Laminar Flow in an In-line and Staggered Array of Circular Cylinders. , to be published 2018.
  2. Fugmann, H.; Di Lauro, P.; Schnabel, L. Heat Transfer Surface Area Enlargement by Usage of Metal Textile Structures – Development, Potential and Evaluation. In International Textile Conference, Dresden; TU Dresden, Ed., 2016.

This article was first published on February 27, 2018 in the blog http://www.minwatercsp.eu/, which informs about the EU project.

Hannes Fugmann

Hannes Fugmann

Hannes Fugmann hat an der Albert-Ludwigs-Universität in Freiburg Mathematik im Diplomstudiengang studiert. Er arbeitet seit 2012 am Fraunhofer-Institut für Solare Energiesysteme ISE in der Abteilung Wärme- und Kältetechnik. Hier beschäftigt er sich hauptsächlich mit der Entwicklung von kompakten und effizienten Wärmeübertragern für die Gebäudeklimatisierung- und Heizung.
Hannes Fugmann has studied Mathematics at the Albert-Ludwigs-University in Freiburg. Since 2012 he is working at the Fraunhofer Institute for Solar Energy Systems ISE in the Heating and Cooling Department. His focus lies on the development of compact and efficient heat exchangers for heating and air conditioning of buildings.
Hannes Fugmann

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *